We
begin by asking the age-old question, "What makes stocks go up and down?"
In a nutshell, stock prices change when either the buyers are willing to pay more
for a stock, or sellers are willing to accept less for a stock. It is a game of
supply and demand, further fueled by investors' greed and fear. However, we focus
on one element that often leads the investment herd into decisions: conventional
wisdom.
Conventional
wisdom is a collection of judgments and perceived insights that are commonly believed
among the masses. In the treacherous world of stock investing, those who follow
conventional wisdom often find themselves on the wrong side of a market move.
Those who make money in the stock market are able to, more often than not, determine
how much of the "conventional wisdom" is based on knowledge, and how
much is based on fluff.
Take
the example of the Internet industry: In the late 1990s, we were told to ignore
profits, ignore stratospherically high P/E ratios, and ignore old tried and true
measures of value. Instead, we were told of the "new economy" and that
stocks could not be valued using the dusty old methods that did not take into
account how much the Internet was "changing the world!" However, as
time passed, not only did many of these Internet stocks perform poorly, many went
out of business. During this time, it turned out that profits were still important,
a business plan still mattered, and a poorly conceived company in any industry,
even a vibrant and growing industry, could still go bankrupt.
Lately,
conventional wisdom seems to be grabbing hold of the headlines again, whenever
the stock market is the topic. The list of reasons stocks are doomed in the coming
weeks and months is a lengthy one: the threat of terrorist attacks, the possibility
of war between India and Pakistan, tensions between Israel and the Palestinians,
accounting irregularities in big corporations, and CEOs who use corporate funds
to furnish their Manhattan apartments with artwork. With all this bad news out
there, how could stocks ever go up again?
To
answer this question, it is useful to turn the question around, and return to
1999. Conventional wisdom at the time held that the Y2K "problem" was
a major one, and that companies and computer systems all over the world would
grind to a halt when the ominous stroke of midnight was reached. Once this fear
passed, it turned out that for the most part, the Y2K fears were overdone. Y2K
actually led many companies to improve business practices, such as data security,
and reliable back-up systems. The stock market roared ahead.
However,
in early 2000, with the Dow nearing 12,000, and the NASDAQ hitting 5,000, things
actually seemed pretty good. Y2K fears were ebbing, the economy was growing at
a bristling pace, stocks were making everyone money, and all seemed good. However,
looking back, this was the point from which the current market decline began.
So,
what is next for the stock market? Over the short run, we simply do not know.
During a bull market, bad news is often discarded and good news is the focus.
During a bear market, like the one we find ourselves stuck in now, good news is
often ignored, as the market focuses on bad news, and the fear of more to come.
This is where conventional wisdom often misses the mark, and leads investors down
a dead-end road.
There
are simply no guarantees in the stock market. But, the U.S. stock market has increased
in value over the last 100 years for the same reasons that it likely will increase
over the next 100 years. The Internet has provided many businesses and employees
with productivity increases. The United States remains the strongest country in
the world, and continues with the process of dealing with those who wish to harm
us and disrupt our way of life. Consumers all over the world continue to demand
products and services that make their lives better. Companies continue to look
for profitable ways to provide these products and services. None of this has changed
- not when a CEO buys a piece of artwork with company funds, not when Enron goes
away, not when the seemingly endless disagreements between Israel and the Palestinians
extend into the new century, and not even when the skyline of Manhattan is forever
changed by international thugs.
Sometimes,
it makes sense to put "conventional wisdom" on the back burner when
making investment decisions.
All material presented is compiled from sources believed to be reliable and current, but accuracy cannot be guaranteed. The contents are intended for general information purposes only. Information provided should not be the sole basis in making any decisions and is not intended to replace the advice of a qualified professional, such as a tax consultant, insurance adviser or attorney. Although this material is designed to provide accurate and authoritative information with respect to the subject matter, it may not apply in all situations. Readers are urged to consult with their adviser concerning specific situations and questions. This is not to be construed as an offer to buy or sell any financial instruments. It is not our intention to state, indicate or imply in any manner that current or past results are indicative of future profitability or expectations. As with all investments, there are associated inherent risks. Please obtain and review all financial material carefully before investing.